Solar panels, wind generators, and hydro-generators: 3 green ways to produce clean energy on a boat

From a performance perspective, rigid photovoltaic panels tend to have slightly higher efficiency compared to flexible panels. This means that, for a given surface area exposed to the sun, rigid panels generate more energy than their flexible counterparts. Moreover, rigid photovoltaic panels generally have a longer lifespan than flexible ones, mainly because the materials they are composed of are more robust, providing better resistance to weathering and wear.

In any case, it can be considered that with a 150 W installation, we will produce between 50 and 100 A in a day depending on the power of the sun and the orientation/exposure of the cells.

Ultimately, there is no one solution better than another: both types of panels (rigid and flexible) have their own features that can be useful depending on the condition of the boat.

Rigid photovoltaic panels offer better energy efficiency, durability over time, and weather resistance, but they are bulkier, heavier, and require a solid and resistant mounting location.

Flexible photovoltaic panels are, on the other hand, lighter, more manageable, and do not require fixed structures to be positioned on. However, they are less resistant to weathering and wear and have slightly lower energy efficiency.

Wind Generators: energy from the wind

Wind generators use the power of the wind to produce electrical energy. These devices, commonly installed on elevated structures (such as the mast, in the case of sailboats), convert the kinetic energy of the wind into electrical energy through a system of turbines. Compared to photovoltaic panels, wind generators can produce energy even at night or in low light conditions, offering a greater source of energy. In general, wind turbines tend to have a nominal power, which is the value used to measure the energy efficiency of a device and is expressed in watts, higher than photovoltaic generators of comparable size. This is because wind generators can harness a source of energy (the wind) that can produce energy even at night or in low light conditions, while photovoltaic panels rely solely on available sunlight during the day. In any case, a good wind generator produces from zero (in the absence of wind) up to 10 or even 15 Ah.

However, the amount of energy actually produced by photovoltaic panels and wind generators depends on multiple variables, such as local weather conditions, wind speed, or solar irradiation. In some areas with constant and strong winds, wind generators may generate more energy than photovoltaic panels, while in other areas with abundant sunlight, photovoltaic panels could be more efficient.

Furthermore, it is important to consider that photovoltaic panels are generally easier to install and require less maintenance compared to wind generators. For the former, periodic cleaning of the modules is enough, while for the latter, maintenance involves more delicate and complex turbine revisions. What’s more, wind turbines require a specific wind thrust to function, without which they remain inactive.

In conclusion, there is no universal answer to which technology generates more power, as it depends on the specific circumstances and environmental conditions of each installation. Both systems have their own advantages and can be used complementarily to maximize the production of energy from renewable sources.

Hydro-Generators: energy from the wave motion

Hydro-generators harness the movement of water to produce electrical energy. Mounted on the boat’s hull, usually aft, they use underwater propellers or turbines to convert the kinetic energy of the waves into electrical energy. This solution is particularly effective during sailing, where movement does not require the engine’s energy input, or in rough sea conditions because the faster the cruising speed, the faster the turbine rotation and therefore the production of electrical energy.

The size and properties of the ideal hydro-generator depend on the characteristics of the boat and the average cruising speed. For example, with a boat cruising at 4 to 6 knots, a 300W hydro-generator might be optimal as it more than compensates for the consumption of about 8 amperes of the onboard system.

For boats larger than 35 feet, it may be useful to install a 600W hydro-generator, which not only provides a greater amount of energy but also produces electricity exponentially starting from speeds of 6 knots.

Solar panels, wind generators, and hydro-generators: conclusions

In an increasingly environmentally conscious world, the use of renewable energy sources on boats has become a recommended choice for those who wish to increase their electrical contribution sustainably. Photovoltaic panels, wind generators, and hydro-generators offer effective solutions for producing clean energy and reducing the environmental impact of boating. Choosing the best solution depends on the specific needs of the boat, typical navigation conditions, and the costs associated with installing the equipment, but one thing is certain: the future of boating, a future that lives in harmony with the environment and high energy performance, is now possible and achievable even with modest investments.